Printer Friendly

Activity: Identifying Amphibians

NGSS Science and Engineering Practices:

NGSS Crosscutting Concepts:

NGSS Disciplinary Core Ideas:


  • Table 5.1
  • Table 5.2
Teacher Guide

Table 5.2. Images of amphibians (Teacher version)


  1. Before beginning the activity, answer question 1 in the Activity Questions below.
  2. Use the dichotomous key in Table 5.1 to determine the identity of each of organisms in Table 5.2. For each organism,
    1. record your decisions from Table 5.1 in the Notes section of Table 5.2;
    2. record the species identity In Table 5.2.
  3. Compare your species identifications and key steps with another student. Discuss any differences.
  4. Obtain the true species identifications from your instructor and compare them to your identifications.
  5. Optional: Using resources available, find an image of an amphibian. Swap images with a classmate and see if you can correctly identify the amphibian.
Table 5.2. Images of amphibians
Specimen Key steps and identity


Activity Questions: 
  1. What are amphibians? Before we can begin to use an amphibian dichotomous key, we need to correctly identify the unknown animals as amphibians.
    1. Write your own definition for “amphibian.” Use simple language that a middle school student would understand.
    2. What are the shared common features that all amphibians possess?
    3. The dichotomous key in Table 5.1 only applies to animals identified as amphibians. Closely examine the images in Table 5.2. Are you certain that all of these animals are amphibians? Why or why not?
  2. Were there any differences between your identifications and the true identifications? Trace your steps working backwards from the correct answer. Where did you make your mistake? Use your mistake to add helpful notes to the dichotomous key for future reference.
  3. Were there any steps in the dichotomous key that were more challenging than others? Explain.
  4. Dichotomous keys are always under revision as new species are discovered and described by biologists. Given the opportunity, how would you revise and improve this simple dichotomous key for amphibians?
  5. If you were shown a photo of a new animal species, what features would you look for to determine if it is an amphibian?
  6. If you were shown a photo of a new animal species, what features would lead you to identify it as a frog?
  7. Step 4 of the dichotomous key in Table 5.1 distinguishes “toads” from “frogs.” However, the colloquial term “toad” generally refers only to one family within the frog grouping (order Anura). All toads are frogs, but not all frogs are toads. How would you modify the dichotomous key to reflect this new information?
  8. The dichotomous key in Table 5.1 provides very broad and general identifications with low taxonomic resolution, or specificity (e.g., it stops at the order level, distinguishing frogs, salamanders, and caecilians).
    1. Compare this key to other dichotomous keys in this module. What is the importance of taxonomic resolution?
    2. What are the benefits of such broad general keys like the one found in Table 5.1?
    3. Describe a real-world situation where general identifications would be sufficient.


Exploring Our Fluid Earth, a product of the Curriculum Research & Development Group (CRDG), College of Education. University of Hawaii, 2011. This document may be freely reproduced and distributed for non-profit educational purposes.