Technical Report #195.
Parkes, J. and P. Fisher. 2017. Review of the Lehua Island rat
eradication project 2009. 48 pages.
1.7 MB
In order to view these
files properly you will need Adobe
Acrobat Reader 5.0
or
higher. Click on the Adobe icon to download |
|
ABSTRACT:
The eradication of introduced mammals is a
prerequisite for a larger program to restore biodiversity on 126-ha
Lehua Island, Hawaii. Rabbits were eradicated by 2006 and an attempt was
made to eradicate the remaining species, the Polynesian rat (Rattus
exulans), in January 2009. Planning for the eradication of rats began in
2005 and covered legislative, regulatory, environmental risk assessment,
operational and contingency response aspects of the project. Aerial
application of rodenticide baits, the most commonly used (and sometimes
only practical) method to eradicate rodents on large or topographically
challenging islands, was chosen as the method for Lehua Island. Two
rodenticide baits containing brodifacoum and one containing diphacinone
rodenticides are registered for aerial application on islands in the
USA. The particular history of rodent control on the larger islands,
public sentiment, and the policy climate in Hawaii meant the use of
diphacinone was favored for the Lehua project.
The use of diphacinone has some major advantages over brodifacoum in
eradicating island rodents (and for sustained control when eradication
is not feasible) largely because its toxicity and environmental
persistence confers lower hazard to non-target wildlife. However,
diphacinone does not have such an established operational history as
brodifacoum, particularly when baits are broadcast from the air. An
analysis of 206 previous eradication attempts against five species of
rodents on islands using brodifacoum or diphacinone is presented in an
appendix to this report. For all methods, 19.6% of 184 attempts using
brodifacoum failed, while 31.8% of 22 attempts using diphacinone failed.
This difference is not statistically significant (Fisher’s Exact Test P
= 0.26). The two toxins have similar failure rates for ground-based
operations (29% for brodifacoum and 23% for diphacinone; Fisher’s Exact
Test P = 0.77). The limited evidence suggests aerial baiting using
brodifacoum has a lower failure rate (11% of 93 attempts) than for
diphacinone (75% but of only 5 attempts) (Fisher’s Exact test P =
0.010). However, we caution against drawing firm conclusions about these
differences because of the small sample size for the diphacinone
attempts.
The attempt to eradicate rats from Lehua Island was therefore a logical
step in expanding the ‘track record’ for effective use of diphacinone in
eradicating rodents. However, 7 months after two aerial applications of
diphacinone bait, Polynesian rats were found on Lehua Island, indicating
that the operation had failed – or that rats had reinvaded the island,
or both.
In early April 2010, the Research Corporation of the University of
Hawaii on behalf of the Hawaii Department of Land and Natural Resources
contracted Landcare Research to review the Lehua Island rat project. The
senior author visited Hawaii between 17 and 21 April 2010 to discuss the
project, and followed this with email and telephone dialogue with the
aim of providing a draft report for comment by 13 May 2010. This draft
report was revised following comments by internal referees and Hawaiian
stakeholders. |